The Sacred Computer:
Thinking Machines, Creativity and Human Development
# 17 November 2026; Created in the year 2000 by Todor Arnaudov - Tosh
"Yet another" rediscovery of methods since the early 2000s which did not go out of fashion in my work, but someone now declares it may return to the mainstream; from a page on Academia.edu:
- At the table of thought : a dialogue on understanding with an artificial interlocutor
2026, Strathprints: The University of Strathclyde institutional repository (University of Strathclyde)
"It is not unfair to suggest that the written dialogue form has fallen out of favour in academic philosophy, despite some relatively recent attempts at its revival (Ruse, 2016; Silliman, 2006) including our own publications that imagine hypothetical discussions between interlocutors with interests in matters pertaining to philosophy of education (Robertson and Prajapati, 2025; Robertson, Prajapati and Chen, 2024). Anecdotal reasons offered by fellow academics as to the decline of the philosophical dialogue include the lack of literary skill of those writing, an inability of authors to inhabit multiple perspectives, and the refusal of journals to accept papers in this format. The rise of generative AI, given that its current most common mode of communication presents as a written dialogue, may offer the opportunity for this form to come into view once more. As an example, the basis of Robert Lieb’s Exoanthropology (2023) is a continuing philosophical discussion with an AI chatbot he refers to as a ‘student’. Lieb is perhaps overly optimistic and a skilful editor of the conversations he engages in with the bot (bearing in mind the version he uses was several iterations ago). ..."
Also: https://strathprints.strath.ac.uk/97764/
Compare for example with the early works from Theory of Universe and Mind (one of which is my "Letters between the 18-year old Todor Arnaudov and the philosopher Angel Grancharov") and the extensive use of dialog as a major method in the seminal "Analysis of the meaning of a sentence, based on the knowledge base of an operational thinking machines. Reflections about the Meaning and Artificial Intelligence*", March 2004 (Анализ на смисъла на изречение въз основа на базата знания на действаща мислеща машина. Мисли за смисъла и изкуствената мисъл., 3.2004) - it demonstrated and simulated LLM "prompt-engineering" and "reasoning" nearly 20 years before this thing was invented by the "other branch".
Yes, I do continue this tradition with the LLMs, see the continuation of the former paper in the appendix "Котката" ("The Cat") from The Prophets of the Thinking Machines: ... https://twenkid.com/agi
*originally - "Artificial Thought"
Google's Overview about the "Analysis..."
https://www.google.com/search?q=Analysis+of+the+meaning+of+a+sentence+todor+arnaudov&oq=Analysis+of+the+meaning+of+a+sentence+todor+arnaudov&aqs=chrome..69i57j33i160.2983j0j7&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8
- Part 1: Semantic Analysis and the Nature of Meaning. Examines how a sentence derives meaning by mapping words onto the internal knowledge base and lived experience of an operational thinking machine.
- Part 2: Causes and Control Units. Explores the underlying reasons for human actions and whether higher cognitive levels or lower instinctive levels hold actual control.
- Part 3: Local Stimuli and Motivation. Argues that motivation is driven by local, specific stimuli rather than abstract generalities, framing pleasure and displeasure as goal-state indicators.
- Part 4: Intelligence as Predictive Reward Optimization. Defines intelligence as a search for the maximum cumulative reward over a given future horizon based on an internal reward model.
- Referential and Experiential Grounding. Arnaudov argues that text is only a compressed end-result of complex cognitive processes. To truly understand a sentence, a thinking machine must ground linguistic symbols in its own multi-modal memory, sensory-motor records, and hierarchical world models.
- Multi-Scale Reinforcement Learning and Bounded Horizons. The essay models human and machine decision-making as a multi-scale reinforcement learning framework. At each decision step, the mind evaluates expected rewards within a limited time horizon, domain, and resolution.
- Fragmented Self and Apparent Irrationality. Because an agent switches between different predictive horizons, domains, and evaluation methods from moment to moment, there is no single, rigid "self". What an outside observer perceives as human "irrationality" is simply a mismatch between the observer's predictive model and the agent's shifting internal reward calculations.
- Early Parallels to Modern AI Research. Written in 2004, the paper anticipates several themes later popularized in cognitive science and machine learning, including symbol grounding, active inference, predictive processing, and the limitations of purely statistical sequence modeling.
- Origins and Publication. Originally written in Bulgarian on March 13, 2004, Arnaudov translated and published the work on his Artificial Mind Blog in January 2010.
- Role in AGI Research. The essay is Part 1 of a two-part series exploring how machines can achieve genuine understanding, paired with Part 2, "Causes and reasons for human actions. Searching for causes".
- Connection to Later Work. Arnaudov cites the reasoning and examples from this 2004 text in his later manuscripts—including his 2025 ResearchGate publication on Stack Theory and the Theory of Universe and Mind—as an early precursor to modern concepts of meaning generation in AI. [1, 2, 3]
- Critique of Shallow NLP. Arnaudov contrasts true semantic comprehension with traditional Natural Language Processing (NLP), arguing that statistical or purely syntactic parsing fails to capture the underlying reality a sentence represents.
- The "Meaning of Meaning." The essay investigates how words and sentences map to internal cognitive models, sensory experiences, and causal structures in the physical world rather than existing merely as isolated linguistic symbols.
See also a today's quick review by the fresh Qwen4-Max, regarding the matches between this work and a 2024 paper:
"1. Originally published in 2004: https://artificial-mind.blogspot.com/2008/02/2004.html The text begins from: "Анализ на смисъла на изречение въз основа на базата знания на действаща мислеща машина. Мисли за смисъла и изкуствената мисъл (2004)" 2. Published in 2024: https://alumni.media.mit.edu/~kris/ftp/foundational-meaning-generation-theory-2024.pdf What are the similar ideas? Is the second echoing major claims from the first? Can you provide citations and reasoning." (Later in the dialog other works from the complete Theory of Universe and Mind, 2001-2004, the foundational AGI theory, were added, as this one was an organic part of the whole and was developing and expressing its ideas)
https://chat.qwen.ai/s/0a903409-11b0-4536-93c8-ae04a7a41690?fev=0.3.45
* See also earlier reviews from 2025 at SIGI-2025.
* Stack Theory is yet another Fork of Theory of Universe and Mind, SIGI-2025
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/398934575_Stack_Theory_is_yet_another_Fork_of_Theory_of_Universe_and_Mind_-_Appendix_Volume_to_The_Prophets_of_the_Thinking_Machines_Artificial_General_Intelligence_and_Transhumanism_History_Theory_and_Pioneers






